Reviews
Rosenbluth focuses her memoir on her early years in the foster care system and on her later experience in Kenya during a yearlong teaching stint. The author, who was born in New York in the mid-1950s, lost her mother at a young age to cancer; her father neglected her and her sister, often leaving them alone to fend for themselves. As a result, the young Rosenbluth often took on a parental role with her sibling, and they both later ended up in foster care, rather than live with other relatives, at her father’s insistence. Despite numerous obstacles on the path to independence, Rosenbluth found a way to attend Friends World College, an international school that promised travel and the multicultural experience that she’d always wanted. Readers follow the teenage Rosenbluth to Songa—a village in rural northern Kenya—eager to teach and help, yet nervous about the prospect of acceptance by the locals, aware of her relative privilege. She was always open to conversation and participation in unfamiliar situations, and soon, she’s forming strong bonds with the Songa community, resulting in enthusiastic interactions in which she and the locals teach one another new things. But old fears continue to haunt Rosenbluth as disagreements regarding religion and the role of women in Kenya threaten her hard-earned friendships and sense of belonging; readers effectively follow both her triumphs and her struggles to keep her place. Overall, Rosenbluth relates vivid memories of Kenya in an engaging prose style (“The road’s red dust drifts up from the ground as we drive, leaving a mushroom-like cloud in the air, shading my vision and filling my nostrils”), and she gets across the vibrant character of many of the people she met. She deftly merges the two parts of her life story—her early life and her Kenyan travels—with maturity and levelheaded reflection and urges readers to both sympathize with others and to pay attention to their own emotional needs. An eye-opening and thorough remembrance, related with clarity and care." — Verdict GET IT Kirkus Review
"Rosenbluth shares her compelling journey of resilience and triumph with such heartbreaking and inspiring honesty that it leaves you on the edge of your seat! She will have you laughing, shaking your head in disbelief, and crying from chapter to chapter, all while holding on to hope that she will prevail against all odds." — Ta’Nika Gibson, actress and advisory board member for You Gotta Believe, a national foster care and adoption advocacy group
A thoughtful memoir about chosen belonging formed through village work in Africa after a childhood of uncertain homes in America. The prose is accessible, and because the writing style feels similar to fiction, it is just so easy to read. — Readers' Favorite Five-Star Book Review
In the middle of a busy workday, I opened the pages of a reviewer’s copy of “Living with Strangers,” planning to earmark a time to start perusing it. Three hours later, I had finished reading it — marveling at the poignancy of a memoir that speaks straight from the heart. Robin Rosenbluth weaves the text in a mix of recollections from her childhood in the U.S. and the year she spent in Songa, a remote semi-nomadic village in Kenya. After her mother’s death, the young Robin and her siblings face major upheavals as their father’s loving behavior changes drastically in the aftermath of the tragedy.
The book opens with her life in Africa with vivid descriptions of the airplane journey and her initial brush with the local people. Even as you are drawn into that rural landscape, a hint of Rosenbluth’s strength seeps through as she describes the first encounter with how to catch and kill a chicken to cook for a meal. Noting she has been a vegetarian for six years prior, she writes about her host’s prowess with the process: “The moment she kills the bird with a knife at its neck is precisely when I lose my smile. But I continue staring — never diverting my gaze during the entire process — thinking this might be a lesson that could come in handy.”
There is something quietly tenacious and gritty in these lines, making the reader aware that her childhood has caused her to be on guard and prepared for anything. As the first few short chapters wind down, notes from her journal provide the segue to how it all started on American soil more than 10 years ago.
“My first entry reads: Your adventure begins at the end of August 1973. You’ve lived with strangers before and survived; you can do this! This is different; this time, you decided to live in Songa. No one is forcing you to be here. If it doesn’t work out, you can leave. You’re an adult now. It’s been years since you lost your mother. You have navigated many hard situations. You can do this.”
As a child living with her family in New York, the winter of 1962 chapter begins on a sunny note with a trip to a gaming parlor with her mother. The mood shifts soon, with hospital visits and the eventual passing of her loving mother. After living for some time at home with siblings, often entrusted with the care of an younger sister, the two girls eventually end up in the child welfare system.
The teenage years spent in foster care challenge the young girl; the candid storytelling reveals how quickly yearnings for the past stability of home life are stifled and a hurried maturity is thrust on her preteen shoulders. As I journey into those difficult years with Rosenbluth, I can feel her sadness in every word. But what also starts to shine through is the resilience of kids in foster care, as the author navigates her new reality with determination amid regular (and a few sudden) heartaches.
While writing about her aunt’s home at one point she notes, “So this is what a loving family life can be. It doesn’t have to be filled with parental anger that lingers. I never feel berated. There’s enough money to eat out and buy clothes. We eat good meals and can have seconds anytime we want. I want to stay here forever.” But she also perseveres soon enough as she secures funding to attend college, travel the world and learn to build meaningful relationships where possible.
Interspersed with her journey to Kenya in the early 1970s, the “braided format” of this book helps connect the dots of her life rather than detract from it. This paragraph sums up the essence of her memoir: “I used to feel powerless — I could never get my father to say anything nice to me after he left us in foster care. Whatever I tried, it never worked. Back then, I couldn’t do anything to change the minds of any of the adults around me or stop them from making my life difficult. But as a young woman in Kenya, I’ve gained more strength and the ability to fight for — and get — what I want when it’s necessary.”
This is why “Living with Strangers” is a book I would recommend for resource parents, foster care alumni and even those currently living with foster, kinship or adoptive families. It is a book celebrating courage, overcoming adversities and finally finding familial comfort — written straight from the heart in a simple, easy-to-follow format. I could not put the book down once I started reading it, and you won’t be able to either.
Sriya Chattopadhyay, Editor of Fostering Families Today Magazine
"Living with Strangers is a beautifully written exploration of connection and belonging. The way she navigates cultural differences while seeking acceptance resonated with me. I found myself invested in her journey, feeling her joys and sorrows as if they were my own. This book is a must-read for anyone who has ever felt like an outsider or has experienced the American foster care system." — Angela Quijada-Banks, author of The Black Foster Youth Handbook
"In this memoir, Robin shares her journey as a foster teen navigating life in strangers’ homes. With the support of caring adults, she finds her way to college. What truly sets her story apart is her year in Kenya at nineteen, living with semi-nomadic tribes and teaching school. Her courage to embrace a new culture while searching for belonging is both surprising and inspiring." — David Ambroz, Author of A Place Called Home
"Robin’s compelling memoir, Living with Strangers, captures her experiences with and appreciation for the people of the Samburu and Rendille tribes in Northern Kenya. She arrived in Kenya with typical teenage anxiety — after struggling to find acceptance from her foster family — and learned to embrace local traditions and culture, as she searched for a place to belong." — Bill Ulfelder, Executive Director of the New York Nature Conservancy
"Weaving her stories as a survivor of the United States’ broken child welfare system and her year in Kenya at nineteen, Robin’s book is a deeply impactful illustration of how leaning into one’s vulnerability can lead to enlightenment and belonging." — Jennifer Pinder, Executive Director of You Gotta Believe
